Introduction
State real estate commissions, sometimes called boards or departments, license real estate salespersons (agents), brokers and brokerages, set licensing standards and requirements, make sure licensees follow state law and discipline those who break it.
In many states the commission does not work alone. It sits within a larger licensing or regulatory agency, such as Pennsylvania’s Bureau of Professional and Occupational Affairs or Michigan’s Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs, which often helps handle complaints, investigations and the public license lookup.
However the work is divided, nearly every commission has the same core mission: protecting the public. The Texas Real Estate Commission says it “exists to safeguard the public interest and protect consumers of real estate services.”[1] North Carolina’s commission describes its principal purpose as protecting “the interests of members of the general public in their dealings with real estate brokers.”[2] California’s Department of Real Estate states that its mission is “to safeguard and promote the public interests in real estate matters through licensure, regulation, education and enforcement.”[3] In fact, out of the 40 mission statements we could find on state commissions’ websites, 30 of them include protecting the public as a priority.
One of the main ways a commission carries out that mission is by making information about its real estate licensees available to the public. Every state offers a free online license lookup, and commissions should encourage consumers to use it before hiring an agent.[4] The lookup matters because it usually shows not only whether an agent has a valid license, but also whether the agent has been disciplined by the state.
Commissions discipline licensees for a wide range of problems, issues, and violations, such as: failing to complete continuing education, letting a license lapse and practicing anyway, failing to carry errors and omissions insurance (in states that require it), mishandling client money, consumer complaints about conduct in a transaction, and criminal charges and convictions, including felonies.
This report discusses what consumers are actually shown when they use this important tool before hiring a licensed real estate agent: the state license lookup. We checked each state’s lookup to see what it tells consumers about the person they are about to hire, including whether the discipline a commission imposes is shared with the public it is meant to protect.
Follow-up reports will examine how hard it is for consumers to find and file a complaint, and how many complaints actually end in public discipline and what that discipline focuses on. None of these findings are meant as a criticism of commission staff, many of whom work with limited resources. Together, the reports identify where current practices fall short of the public protection mission these agencies were created to serve, and what can be done to close those gaps.
Methodology
From September through November 2026, our researcher examined each state’s official real estate license search portal, usually called a license lookup, as a consumer. In most states we searched for a licensee with a known disciplinary history documented in commission orders, newsletters or public postings. When that was not available, we searched news coverage for agents charged with a crime within the past five years. For each state we recorded three things:
- Easy to find: Does the record show clearly that an action exists upfront, without scrolling or clicking elsewhere?
- Easy to understand what happened: Does it explain the disciplinary action in plain language?
- Shows past brokerage employment: Does it list the brokerages the licensee has worked for?
This is a snapshot of known entries in each state, not an audit of every record. License sites change, so findings reflect the lookups on the dates searched. Kentucky, Washington and Wyoming are marked inconclusive due to lack of access to disciplinary reports and crime searches did not return enough usable results.
What The Lookup Shows
Across the 47 states with results, the public lookup worked effectively for consumers in only a handful. Only 3 states — Delaware, Idaho and Illinois — flagged the action in the first summary or search result a consumer sees. In 27 more, the action appeared only after the consumer clicked into the licensee’s profile or scrolled down the page, while the summary that appears first, often showing the agent’s name, license status and expiration date, carried no flag. In the remaining 17 states, a consumer looking up an agent with a known disciplinary record could not find the action on the lookup at all. Only 8 states described the violation in plain language, and only Illinois both flagged the action up front and explained it. Only 2 showed the brokerages an agent has worked for in the past, Arizona and California. Table 1 shows each state’s result on the three questions.
| State | Easy to find | Easy to understand what happened | Shows past brokerage employment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alabama | Somewhat | Yes | No |
| Alaska | Somewhat | No | No |
| Arizona | Somewhat | Yes | Yes |
| Arkansas | No | No | No |
| California | Somewhat | No | Yes |
| Colorado | Somewhat | No | No |
| Connecticut | Somewhat | No | No |
| Delaware | Yes | No | No |
| Florida | Somewhat | No | No |
| Georgia | No | No | No |
| Hawaii | No | No | No |
| Idaho | Yes | No | No |
| Illinois | Yes | Yes | No |
| Indiana | Somewhat | Yes | No |
| Iowa | Somewhat | No | No |
| Kansas | Somewhat | No | No |
| Kentucky | Inconclusive | Inconclusive | Inconclusive |
| Louisiana | Somewhat | No | No |
| Maine | Somewhat | No | No |
| Maryland | No | No | No |
| Massachusetts | Somewhat | No | No |
| Michigan | Somewhat | No | No |
| Minnesota | No | No | No |
| Mississippi | No | No | No |
| Missouri | Somewhat | No | No |
| Montana | Somewhat | No | No |
| Nebraska | Somewhat | Yes | No |
| Nevada | No | No | No |
| New Hampshire | Somewhat | No | No |
| New Jersey | No | No | No |
| New Mexico | Somewhat | No | No |
| New York | No | No | No |
| North Carolina | No | No | No |
| North Dakota | No | No | No |
| Ohio | No | No | No |
| Oklahoma | No | No | No |
| Oregon | Somewhat | Yes | No |
| Pennsylvania | Somewhat | No | No |
| Rhode Island | No | No | No |
| South Carolina | Somewhat | No | No |
| South Dakota | No | No | No |
| Tennessee | Somewhat | Yes | No |
| Texas | Somewhat | Yes | No |
| Utah | No | No | No |
| Vermont | Somewhat | No | No |
| Virginia | Somewhat | No | No |
| Washington | Inconclusive | Inconclusive | Inconclusive |
| West Virginia | No | No | No |
| Wisconsin | Somewhat | No | No |
| Wyoming | Inconclusive | Inconclusive | Inconclusive |
*”Yes” means the action is flagged in the first summary or search result, before clicking. “Somewhat” means it appears only after clicking into the licensee’s profile or scrolling through the profile. “No” means it does not appear on the lookup, or the consumer must go to a separate page or download a file to find it. Dark grey marks No. Kentucky, Washington and Wyoming were inconclusive.[5]
The warning is buried or behind extra clicks
Even where an action appears on the lookup, consumers often have to know where to look.
- Oregon does not show discipline on its results page. It appears only after a consumer clicks “details,” but they do give a brief mention of the issues that occurred with additional pdfs.
- Michigan makes the consumer click a small icon that leads to another page with a PDF link.
- Kansas lists violations only after several clicks, and then only as statute numbers with no explanation.
- Wisconsin files actions under “Orders” and does not note them at the top. A consumer may not realize an order is a disciplinary action. They also have to download the PDF to learn what happened.
- Georgia requires a PDF download to find out what harm the licensee caused.
- New Mexico requires an extra click and then you must download and read the legal attachments. It’s worth noting that this state has not updated their public disciplinary page since February 2024.
Actions are published, but not on the lookup
Several states publish disciplinary actions somewhere on their website but never connect them to the licensee’s record. A consumer who checks the lookup, as commissions advise, sees no record of action.
- Arkansas does a good job of explaining a disciplinary action in plain language on their batched disciplinary postings,[6] but none of that information appears in the license lookup.
- Hawaii sends consumers elsewhere to see actions, although it does highlight licensees’ names who cannot practice (due to inactive or expired license) in bright red.
- Maryland posts actions in batches on a separate disciplinary page on their website, but those actions do not appear when a consumer looks up the licensee, and the batch list gives little detail. Maryland does other things well for consumers, including complaint handling and recovery fund help, but none of it carries over to the lookup.
- Minnesota posts actions in plain language, but only in batches on their separate disciplinary page. When pulling up a license, it notes at the very bottom that a violation might have occurred, but then tells the consumers to call or search elsewhere.
- Nevada prints actions in its commission newsletter but they do not appear in the license lookup.
- North Carolina posts actions in batches elsewhere on their website without license numbers, which makes it hard to tell apart licensees with similar names.
- West Virginia does not include disciplinary actions on the lookup. Commission staff said adding them would cost more. It is the only state that appears to steer consumers to the ARELLO national platform instead.[7]
- Missouri does note when a licensee has (or had) a disciplinary action but does not include any explanation for action, yet details are included on the batched public disciplinary page elsewhere on their website.
- New Jersey showed nothing for licensees with actions in the lookup. It’s worth noting it made only four disciplinary actions public in fiscal year 2025 while overseeing more than 96,000 licensees.
- South Dakota only shows disciplinary actions in its newsletters and does not include them in its lookup.
The record says one thing, the lookup says another
- New Hampshire recently released a newer licensing system but still listed “no” for disciplinary action on a licensee it had disciplined earlier this year for unprofessional conduct. Another licensee’s violation appeared with a green checkmark next to “disciplinary action” which could make consumers believe that means they don’t have one, when in fact, they do.
- Massachusetts notes “fine assessed” under current action, only after a consumer clicks for more details, with no amount or reason. The fine does not appear on the printed license page.
- Louisiana mentions a licensee’s past suspension and wire fraud conviction only as a bolded line under education history, next to the required course.
- Ohio showed no violation for a licensee disciplined for failing to deposit earnest money on time and failing to notify the seller’s side. The field to insert a real estate license number is also confusing for consumers to utilize.
- Utah showed no violation for a licensee disciplined this year for acting as a dual agent without consent.
- Oklahoma did not show a 2025 action in which a managing broker who failed to report a felony guilty plea agreed to step down to broker associate and wait two years before he can manage a brokerage again. His license history still lists his past managing broker licenses as “Active.”
- Rhode Island did not show a 2025 action for a licensee giving inaccurate information on how their client could cancel their contract with them.
- North Carolina has a single field for the name. Searching the licensee’s first and last name together returned nothing. Searching just their last name returned every person with that last name in the state, to which we finally found them listed with their first and middle name.
Work history is almost invisible
An employer reviewing a résumé of a candidate who has moved from job to job would raise a cautionary flag. A licensee who hops from brokerage to brokerage can raise the same concern. Frequent moves may point to problems with competence or a history of poor client experiences. Only Arizona and California show the brokerages an agent has worked for. In every other state, a consumer cannot see whether an agent has moved from firm to firm or been let go, which could reflect incompetence or failure to adhere to ethical standards.
No common vocabulary
States describe disciplinary actions in many different ways: “Orders” (Wisconsin), “Case History” (Vermont), “Click to view public documents” (Michigan), an administrative code citation (Iowa), and entries filed under employment or education history (New Hampshire, Louisiana, Ohio). A consumer may not understand that these terms refer to disciplinary actions.
Disciplines Consumers Never See
A real estate commission exists to protect the public, as well as to educate and correct licensees’ behavior. Yet many commissions can close a case with a private letter never disclosed to the public, even when a licensee broke the rules. In some states, these letters are not posted with disciplinary actions and do not appear on the license lookup.
Oregon has made this its policy. Its real estate commissioner wrote in June 2026 that the agency’s goal “is to educate first and only suspend or revoke for repeated or more egregious violations.”[8] Its Educational Letters of Advice for minor violations are not considered discipline, are kept out of the agency’s disciplinary records and are expunged after six years. The agency does not share the names of licensees who receive them. Oregon issued 106 of these letters in 2025, nearly three for every one of its 39 public disciplinary actions.
Education should be part of the response to a violation, but the violation should also be disclosed to the public. A licensee’s mishandling of a transaction, even if considered minor, is exactly what a consumer needs to know before hiring that agent. Consumers can distinguish between violations that are minor or major.
How States Handle Felonies And Arrests
Licensing boards act quickly on some problems and violations, but not at all on others. In Illinois, the real estate license law lets regulators refuse to renew or suspend the license of anyone who fails to file a tax return or pay taxes owed, and a licensee more than 30 days behind on child support faces the same risk.[9] No criminal case is needed. A felony, by contrast, becomes grounds for discipline under the same law only after a conviction or plea (225 ILCS 454/20-20). Other states also wait for a plea, or act only if the felony occurred during a transaction. Innocent until proven guilty matters, but licensed agents are invited into consumers’ homes, handle the finances in a transaction and are often around children. For some felonies, the risk is too great to wait for a plea.
Texas left a licensee charged with possession of child sexual abuse material licensed,[10] and working with families in their homes, for more than three years after charges were filed. The commission did not revoke the license until September 2026.[11] During that time, a consumer searching the lookup would have seen an active license with no disciplinary history.[12] Even a conviction does not guarantee prompt action. Another Texas licensee was indicted for COVID-19 relief fraud by a U.S. Attorney’s Office in February 2024[13] and sentenced in December 2025,[14] but kept her license until April 2026.[15]
The Texas Real Estate Commission says it “does not have the authority to revoke or suspend a license holder that has been only charged or accused.” That is true of its regular discipline, which follows a conviction or a guilty or no contest plea. But Texas law also gives the commission an emergency tool. Under Section 1101.662 of the Real Estate Licensee Act,[16] a three-member panel must temporarily suspend a license when the licensee’s continued practice would be a continuing threat to the public welfare, and it can act without advance notice or a hearing. The statute does not require a conviction or a plea.
In Tennessee, a licensee was indicted in 2026 on charges including aggravated sexual exploitation of a minor.[17] A petition, started in 2025 with nearly 600 signatures, was already asking the commission to suspend his license.[18] While the article states his license was surrendered “again,” the lookup system currently lists him as “retired” with no past actions shown. Unlike a license revocation, in Tennessee, a licensee can reinstate their retired license by writing a request and paying a fee.[19]
In Louisiana, a licensee kept his license for 138 days after his arrest on felony hit-and-run charges.[20] The pedestrian he struck died, and a negligent homicide charge was added. During that window he joined a new brokerage.[21] In contrast, that same year the commission issued emergency orders suspending two licensees 10 and 22 days after their arrests on theft charges involving clients’ money.[22] Neither had pleaded guilty or been convicted; the commission acted on the arrests alone.
Even the handling of drunk driving charges varies, from probation after multiple charges in some states to suspension after a single charge in others.
Everyone makes mistakes, and a criminal charge is not a conviction. Licensees deserve the presumption of innocence, and second chances have a real place in professional licensing. But some charges carry risks too serious to delay action. When an agent is charged with crimes involving children, abuse, assault, murder, or financial fraud, consumers are still letting that person into their homes, around their families and into the middle of one of the largest financial transactions of their lives. A temporary suspension while the charges are resolved is not a verdict. It is a reasonable step to protect the public, and the license can be restored if the person is cleared.
The technology to flag offenders already exists
The FBI’s Rap Back service gives enrolled agencies real-time notice of new criminal activity by people in positions of trust whose fingerprints are on file.[23] It works for real estate. In Missouri, a Rap Back report from the State Highway Patrol is how the commission learned that a licensee had pleaded guilty to two felony drug charges he never disclosed.[24] Utah has required every real estate agent, broker and appraiser to be fingerprinted and enrolled in Rap Back since 2020.[25] Brokers already licensed had to be fingerprinted before their next renewal period. Many commissions already fingerprint applicants. The question is whether they act on what that system tells them in a quick fashion.
Records That Can’t Be Found, Or That Change
On occasion, a search for a specific licensee returned no results. Researchers tried first name only, last name only and initials. Even then, some licensees did not appear, even though they had been charged with a crime or disciplined publicly. Sometimes a record is missing because the person was inactive, but in our research it also occurred for other reasons.
- Arizona: One agent’s name and license history could no longer be found in the state’s search tool a few days after he was arrested for alleged racist and aggressive behavior on an airplane on September 4, 2026.[26] By October 12, with the media on to other stories, the record was able to be searched again.
- California: A licensee interviewed as a whistleblower now had a gap of roughly 18 months in their official license history, even though a public portal still showed the brokerage they worked for during that period.[27]
- New York: A broker is no longer with the firm after a couple filed a Fair Housing lawsuit alleging she sent a text reading “Ugh. They are Black” as they arrived for a showing in June 2026.[28] Yet in researching her license, she is unable to be found.[29] It is unclear whether she was removed from the lookup due to lack of a broker attachment or because of recent events. Regardless of licensee status, the license history should remain visible to the public.
Some of these records may cast a poor light on an agent, broker, or brokerage, but public information is public and should not be removed because of a brokerage change or public relations crisis.
One agent, multiple states and no connection
Agents who work near a state line often hold licenses in two or three states. Each state keeps its own record, and those records rarely talk to each other, meaning a consumer checking an agent’s license in one state sees only what that state knows.
Mortgage loan originators, the professionals who often work alongside real estate agents in the same transaction, can be researched through a nationwide system. Through its free license lookup, NMLS Consumer Access, anyone can search a loan officer once and see every state where that person is licensed, along with public regulatory actions taken against them.[30] Real estate consumers have nothing like it. To get the full picture, a consumer with close bordering states would have to know every state where their agent is licensed and search each one separately.
One licensee based in northern Delaware, which borders three states within a 30-minute drive, shows how much can be missed. In 2023, Pennsylvania cited her for practicing without a license, yet her Delaware record does not show it.[31] In October 2026, that same licensee paid $80,000 to settle federal allegations that she bought a Housing and Urban Development (HUD) home as an owner-occupant and flipped it within six months.[32] She is not alone. In 2022, a Pennsylvania broker, along with two other licensed agents, entered pretrial diversion on federal charges over the same kind of HUD scheme, and the group paid HUD $80,000 without admitting liability.[33]
HUD gives families who plan to live in a foreclosed home the first chance to buy it, before investors can bid. When an agent poses as an owner-occupant to flip a home, a family that wants to live there loses their opportunity at homeownership. Yet, because none of these HUD cases ended in a conviction, although settlements were paid, none of the PA licensees showed this information on their disciplinary actions. It is unclear how Delaware will handle the most recent HUD case with their public actions.
The closest multi-state search system available is run by the association of real estate regulators (ARELLO). While they maintain a database of disciplinary action, it is available only to regulators and those acting on their behalf, not to consumers. This database is new and currently has only 15 participating jurisdictions actively sharing and updating actions, so even regulators may not see the full picture.[34]
Real estate is licensed state by state, but the agents consumers hire do not always stay inside state lines. When a licensee is disciplined, settles fraud allegations or practices without a license in one state, consumers in every state where that person is licensed deserve to know.
How The States Rate
To compare states, we scored each lookup on the same three questions shown in Table 1. The questions are weighted by how much each one matters to a consumer deciding whether to hire an agent. Finding the action matters most, because a consumer who never sees it has nothing to weigh. Understanding what happened comes next, because a missed education credit and a pattern of consumer complaints call for very different decisions. Work history is useful context, so it counts, but for less.
Scoring method
Each state could earn up to 8 points:
- Easy to find (up to 4 points). A state earned 4 points if the action was flagged in the first summary or search result a consumer sees, 2 points if it appeared only after clicking into the licensee’s profile or scrolling, and no points if it did not appear on the lookup at all or required going to a separate page or downloading a file.
- Easy to understand what happened (up to 3 points). A state earned 3 points if it explained in plain language what the licensee did and what the penalty was, 1 point if it provided the commission’s order or another legal document without an explanation, and no points if it provided neither.
- Shows past brokerage employment (1 point). A state earned 1 point if the lookup listed the brokerages the licensee has worked for.
States were then placed in three tiers:
- Good (6-8): The license lookup gives consumers clear, easy-to-find information about the person they might hire, including any discipline and what it was for.
- Needs Improvement (3-5): The lookup gives some information, but a consumer would have to dig or guess to make an informed decision about hiring.
- Poor (0-2): The lookup does not tell consumers what they need to know before hiring. A consumer could check it, as the commission advises, and still hire an agent with a disciplinary record without knowing it.
Because finding the action carries the most weight, a state whose lookup does not show the action at all can score no more than 4 points and cannot rate Good, even if it explains the action well.
Results
Of the 47 states we could rate, only 2 rated Good: Illinois and Arizona. 21 rated Needs Improvement and 24, more than half of all states rated, rated Poor. 16 states scored zero, meaning a consumer who followed the commission’s advice and checked the lookup would have found no sign of the action, no document and no work history.
Illinois flags the action on the licensee’s summary and explains it in plain language. Arizona explains the action and shows past brokerages, but a consumer has to click into the profile and scroll to find it. No state earned all 8 points, since Arizona does not flag the action up front and Illinois does not show work history.
The states rated as follows:
Good (2 states): Illinois (7 points); Arizona (6 points).
Needs Improvement (21 states): Alabama, Delaware, Idaho, Indiana, Nebraska, Oregon, Tennessee and Texas (5 points each); California (4 points); Alaska, Colorado, Connecticut, Maine, Michigan, Montana, New Mexico, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Vermont, Virginia and Wisconsin (3 points each).
Poor (24 states): Florida, Iowa, Kansas, Louisiana, Massachusetts, Missouri and New Hampshire (2 points each); Minnesota (1 point); 16 states with no points: Arkansas, Georgia, Hawaii, Maryland, Mississippi, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, Rhode Island, South Dakota, Utah and West Virginia.
Not rated: Kentucky, Washington and Wyoming, because results were inconclusive.
A Look Ahead: AI Missed It Too
One in five consumers are now utilizing AI in their homebuying journey,[35] so our researcher also tested whether AI could answer the most basic question: has this agent been disciplined by the state? In November 2026, we used Claude Opus 5.5, a current AI model from Anthropic. Although we used a paid account, we used it the way most people do with a free one.[36] We gave it each agent’s name, license number and state, and asked it to tell us about the agent and check whether they have any disciplinary actions with the state. The AI could search the web to answer, a feature free accounts also have, but we did not use paid tools that let AI open websites and search state license lookups on our behalf. We gave it the same licensees our researcher looked up for this report, in the 47 states we were able to rate.
In most states, AI came up empty. In 34 of the 47 states, it found no record of any action. A consumer asking AI about these agents would have been told nothing and could easily have taken that silence as a clean record. The misses included Illinois and Arizona, the two states that rated Good in our review, along with Alabama, California and Texas, because their discipline lives inside lookup tools that web searches cannot open.
Where AI did find a record, in 13 states, it was almost never on a page about the agent. It came from commission meeting minutes and agendas, signed orders posted as PDFs and discipline newsletters. The penalties ranged from a $500 fine to a license suspension. In 8 of those states, the lookup itself scored zero: Arkansas, Maryland, Mississippi, Nevada, New Jersey, North Carolina, Oklahoma and West Virginia. The information was public, just not where commissions tell consumers to look.
Recommendations
- Flag actions on the main page. Any disciplinary action should be noted in search results and at the top of the licensee’s main record, not behind another tab, link or page. Where a lookup shows a summary pop-up with an option for full details, the pop-up itself should show “Yes” or “No” for disciplinary actions. The flag should be in a caution color such as red or amber, never green. Consumers should not be expected to comb through newsletters and yearly disciplinary posts to try and verify license history.
- Use words that signal discipline. Label these records “Disciplinary Actions,” not “Orders,” “Consents,” “Case History” or “Public Documents.”
- Explain what happened in plain language. Each action should come with a brief recap of what the licensee did, why the commission acted and the penalty. Legal PDFs can sit behind that recap but should not replace it. A consumer may feel differently about an agent who missed an education course credit than about one with repeated violations where consumers were harmed, and only a plain description lets them decide.
- Keep records searchable and permanent. Some states allow years to pass before filing a complaint, in which the consumer needs access to licenses and brokerage responsibility, even when they have expired or are inactive. For that reason alone, records should stay public when a license is inactive, expired, surrendered or revoked, when a licensee is in the news, and after the licensee completes the terms of discipline. If a state allows removal, it should require a long waiting period and a published standard; never apply it to theft, trust fund or consumer harm cases, and keep a note on the record that an older action existed.
- Show work history. List past brokerages with dates. An agent with a long list of past brokerages and short time periods should be a cautionary mark for consumers.
- Disclose letters and warnings. Commissions that resolve cases with educational or warning letters should note on the record that a letter was issued and for what kind of conduct, and publish how many they send each year. Any letter issued after a violation is found should be public.
- Report housing and consumer protection violations, not just convictions. All commissions should require licensees to report, within 30 days, any federal or state action involving housing or consumer protection, including fraud in HUD and FHA programs, mortgage fraud, fair housing discrimination, kickbacks, disclosure violations and deceptive practices. This should include civil settlements, pretrial diversion and federal exclusions.
- Act on serious charges. Every state should enroll licensees in fingerprint-based Rap Back monitoring and use interim suspension while serious felony charges are resolved, regardless of whether the charge is related to a transaction. The public should be told when a licensee is under such a restriction.
- Make discipline visible to search engines and AI tools. The license lookup should remain the official, authoritative record of a licensee’s history. But as more consumers turn to search engines and AI tools to research the people they hire, that same information should also be reachable outside the lookup. Commissions should publish each disciplinary action on a public page that search engines can read, labeled with the licensee’s full name and license number, and link it from the licensee’s lookup record. This way, a consumer gets the same answer whether they search the lookup directly or ask an AI tool.
Conclusion
In most states, the law requires its real estate commission to protect the public. One of the most basic ways to do that is to provide important information about disciplinary actions taken against licensees.
This report found that in most states, that check will not tell consumers what they most need to know. Disciplinary actions are buried, mislabeled, kept off the lookup or never made public at all. Agents charged with serious crimes can stay licensed and show a clean record for months or years. And on the rare occasion when an agent is in the news, the record itself can disappear for a time and reappear later.
None of these gaps requires new authority to fix. Commissions already decide what their lookups display, how they label them and what they publish. A clear flag, a plain-language summary, permanent and searchable records, and prompt action on serious charges are choices within reach of every state. The real estate commission is the protector of the public. It should tell them the truth about who they are about to let into their home, trust with their finances and allow around their children.
Some fixes work best when states act together. Many agents along state borders hold licenses in more than one state, but each state’s record stands alone, and a consumer has no single place to see the full picture. The pieces of a solution already exist. ARELLO, the association of real estate regulators, maintains a national disciplinary database for its members, and the mortgage industry’s NMLS Consumer Access shows that one free, public search across every state is possible. States should commit to reporting all public discipline to a shared system, and ARELLO and its members should open a consumer version: one search that shows every state where an agent is licensed and any public action taken in each.
A license lookup can only show what reaches the public record, and for most consumers that record starts with a complaint. Our next report follows a complaint from start to finish: how easy it is for a consumer to find and file one, what happens once it is submitted, and how many complaints end in discipline the public can actually see. We rate each state’s complaint process using the same Good, Needs Improvement and Poor scale, and the rankings shift once again. A state that makes discipline easy to find does not always make it easy to report a problem, and some states that fall short on the lookup do better when a consumer files a complaint.
[1] https://www.trec.texas.gov/node/119
[2] https://bulletins.ncrec.gov/commission-spotlight-regulatory-affairs/
[3] https://dre.ca.gov/about/MissionStatement.html
[4] http://dre.ca.gov/Newsroom/DRE_Updates/2025_03_26_ChoosingAnAgent.html
[5] New York’s rating reflects a licensee arrested in May 2025 on felony forgery and identity theft charges tied to a real estate transaction. As of November 2026, her license was active with no actions or notes shown. We could not determine the outcome of the criminal case, and the Department of State had not published any action. https://troopers.ny.gov/news/state-police-arrest-saratoga-county-realtor-forgery
[6] https://arec.arkansas.gov/enforcement/hearing-disciplinary-actions-date/
[7] https://arello.org/resources/disciplinary-action-database/
[8] https://www.oregon.gov/rea/newsroom/Pages/2026_OREN-J/Education-FIrst-Commissioner-Column.aspx
[9] https://www.ilga.gov/documents/legislation/ilcs/documents/022504540K20-20.htm
[10] State of Texas v. Lance Huebel, Case No. 23-0537-K368, 368th District Court, Williamson County, Texas.
[11] https://www.trec.texas.gov/license-search/?detail_id=1831843
[12] https://www.homes.com/real-estate-agents/lance-huebel/5k55b1m/
[13] https://www.justice.gov/usao-wdmo/pr/11-defendants-indicted-220000-covid-fraud-conspiracy
[14] https://www.irs.gov/compliance/criminal-investigation/texas-woman-sentenced-for-quarter-million-dollar-covid-fraud
[15] https://www.trec.texas.gov/license-search/?detail_id=1895106
[16] https://law.justia.com/codes/texas/occupations-code/title-7/subtitle-a/chapter-1101/subchapter-n/section-1101-662/
[17] https://www.wkrn.com/news/local-news/murfreesboro/murfreesboro-real-estate-agent-faces-child-exploitation-charges/
[18] https://www.change.org/p/revoke-justin-holder-s-real-estate-license-in-murfreesboro-tn
[19] https://www.law.cornell.edu/regulations/tennessee/Tenn-Comp-R-Regs-0780-05-07-.06
[20] https://lsp.org/community-outreach/news/arrest-made-in-livingston-parish-hit-and-run-crash-following-anonymous-tips/
[21]https://portal.lrec.gov/Public/LRECBrokerageHistory/?key=%27Z6ETQgiGO0U8555r90l2rg%3d%3d%27
[22] Louisiana Real Estate Commission, Emergency Order 2025-002 and 2025-003
[23] https://www.fbi.gov/file-repository/pias/pia-ngi-rap-back-service.pdf/view
[24] https://pr.mo.gov/boards/realestate/discipline/Beck,%20Derek-Order%20for%20Motion%20to%20Set%20Aside%202026.pdf
[25] https://le.utah.gov/~2019/bills/sbillint/SB0140.pdf
[26] https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/sep/08/racist-plane-real-estate-agent-tied
[27] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4lGNKRawxrY&t=1133s
[28] https://www.theroot.com/an-agent-s-alleged-racist-text-shatters-a-couple-s-drea-2000132035
[29] New York Department of State license search, https://appext20.dos.ny.gov/nydos/searchByName.do, search for Helen Tzelios.
[30] https://www.nmlsconsumeraccess.org/Home.aspx/MainSearch
[31] PA disciplinary file 23-56-009032
[32] https://www.justice.gov/usao-de/pr/delaware-real-estate-agent-agrees-pay-80000-resolve-false-claims-act-allegations
[33] https://www.hudoig.gov/sites/default/files/2026-07/pe-12.pdf
[34] https://arello.org/resources/disciplinary-action-database/
[35] https://www.nar.realtor/news/real-estate-news/technology/ai-becomes-early-step-in-homebuying-journey
[36] https://www.npr.org/2026/06/04/nx-s1-5791661/chatgpt-gemini-claude-subscription-revenue-openai
October 1, 2019
Public Comment
Letter to the SEC: Proposed Private Offering Expansion Threatens Investor Protections and Market Transparency